
PopGap #17: The Best of Youth (2003)
Written by dorrk | 31 May 2016 |
The Movie Slot Machine: 12 Random Movies, One Specific Viewer
I can usually understand, if not at least partially appreciate, the appeal of any movie that is received with overwhelming praise, but I have nothing for Marco Tullio Giordana's inexplicably awful six-hour Italian made-for-TV epic The Best of Youth. Winner of the 2003 Cannes Film Festival's Prix Un Certain Regard, and chalking up an impressive 8.5/10 rating on IMDb, an 89% score from Metacritic, and a staggering 95% on the Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer, I counted only two better-than-average scenes in a whopping 366 minutes, and one of those scenes was ruined within seconds. It is an utterly artless soap opera that charts 40 years in the "lives" of vapid caricatures, superficially leading them through a few random touchstones of recent Italian cultural history to the droning thrum of monotonous sentimentality. My best guess at this ineptly laughable tearjerker's stunning popularity is that most reviewers took one look at the running time and bailed, filing a blind evaluation based on the expectation of a respectable level of professionalism behind the camera and, with so much material, a semi-novelistic depth of storytelling. None of that here.
Alessio Boni and Luigi Lo Cascio star as brothers Matteo and Nicola Carati, Matteo a moody and reserved teen "genius" of whom great things are expected, and Nicola a good-natured and easy-going pre-med student. However, a summer holiday throws both of their lives off-balance, when Matteo smuggles an abused patient (Jasmine Trinca) out of a mental hospital, determined to return her to her father. When this adventure predictably turns sour, Matteo turns his back on intellectual pursuits and enlists in the military; Nicola's idealism is stoked, and he bums around Norway before pursuing a career in mental health advocacy. For the next three-to-four decades, the two brothers' lives diverge substantially, occasionally crossing paths now and again, usually in the most convoluted manner. Italy, during that span, experiences World Cup losses and victories, natural tragedies, youth riots, leftist terrorism, and political assassinations.
For an endeavor of such massive volume, The Best of Youth is shockingly low on subtext. It's the kind of movie in which characters frequently describe the obvious or state the simple facts of their feelings, and often as ham-handedly as possible. Rather than weaving a complex tale of two brothers whose lives reverberate against one another despite great spans of time and distance, its parallel narratives are shockingly linear and simplistic, with internal and external conflicts proceeding in lockstep and lacking dynamic tension. While director Marco Tullio Giordana eschews the sensationalism of soap operas — opting instead for a static tone of precious emotionalism — he offers no creativity in terms of form or style. Bereft of visual artistry, The Best of Youth is stuck in a relentlessly repetitive series of TV-quality establishing shots and close-ups. When, three or four times, a brief glimmer of cinematic inspiration interrupts the funeral procession of ordinariness, it feels like a violation rather than a release.
Giordana takes only the most blase approach to evoking his film's changing eras, resulting in a long slog of blandly connected plot points. Only rarely do the historical events depicted impact the characters; they mostly play-out in the background or provide a momentary inconvenience — or worse, suggest that some sort of eventful confluence may well come to pass, only for it to never happen. There's a shocking carelessness to how sloppily these totemistic references to real life are broached and then dropped, but Giordana does the same with characters, as well; everything is episodic, but the episodes themselves are structureless, disconnected and meaningless, there only to serve an eventual series of sentimentally fueled time bombs that fizzle under the wet blanket of inevitability. The Best of Youth is stocked with telegraphed revelations, but the pacing between the hinting and fruition is so painfully obstinate (in the worst case, over an hour of movie time and nearly 10 years in the characters' lives) that their resolution is exasperating rather than satisfying. For a movie that has nothing to say dramatically, historically, artistically, or personally, there sure is a lot of it.
There are, relatively, bright spots in The Best of Youth. the acting is uniformly competent, although it rarely rises above the mediocrity of the material; but Maya Sansa's presence in the final 90 minutes (or maybe it was Stockholm Syndrome) goes a long way to making that stretch the movie's most agreeable, considerably easing the strain of the running time. the first hour is mildly intriguing before the promise of the rave reviews evaporates completely, and there are a few nicely acted and written scenes throughout — one of the best, not surprisingly, involves neither brother but two mostly peripheral characters. Giordana almost saved his best scene for last, with an uncharacteristically beautiful and tender moment that lingers achingly before almost instantly being ruined by an intrusion of the most staggeringly graceless, hilariously literal explication of the obvious. It perfectly sums the entire experience of struggling through this gargantuan sinkhole of production facilities that has mysteriously come to be beloved by many.
Trailer for the Best of Youth (2003)

The Best of Youth (2003)
More info
Full list of all criteria loaded into the Movie Slot Machine for May:
View Movie Selection Rules
I post reviews for all the movies on this blog, and live-tweet most viewings here:
https://twitter.com/popgap
This list is posted to Letterboxd, here:
https://letterboxd.com/dorrk/list/popgap-2016-05-movie-slot-machine/
You can keep track of my Flickchart here:
http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=dorrk
Movie Slot Machine Rules
- Actor: Angela Winkler
- Actor: Anna Karina
- Actor: Anne Baxter
- Actor: Anne Parillaud
- Actor: Anouk Aimée
- Actor: Bulle Ogier
- Actor: Catherine Deneuve
- Actor: Celia Johnson
- Actor: Dorothy Mackaill
- Actor: Franco Nero
- Actor: Humphrey Bogart
- Actor: Ingrid Bergman
- Actor: Irène Jacob
- Actor: Jack Hawkins
- Actor: Jean Gabin
- Actor: Jean Simmons
- Actor: Jean-Louis Trintignant
- Actor: Jeanne Crain
- Actor: Jeffrey Wright
- Actor: Lee Remick
- Actor: Mads Mikkelsen
- Actor: Margaret O'Brien
- Actor: Marie Prevost
- Actor: Marion Cotillard
- Actor: Mary Elizabeth Winstead
- Actor: Mathieu Amalric
- Actor: Max Von Sydow
- Actor: Miriam Hopkins
- Actor: Monica Vitti
- Actor: Patricia Neal
- Actor: Paul Giamatti
- Actor: Robert Ryan
- Actor: Klaus Kinksi
- Actor: Tahar Rahim
- Actor: Taraji P. Henson
- Actor: Teresa Wright
- Actor: Trevor Howard
- Actor: Ursula Andress
- Actor: Viggo Mortensen
- Actor: William Bendix
- Actor: Yasuaki Kurata
- Actor: Daniel Auteiul
- Actor: Michael Shannon
- Actor: Nastassja Kinski
- Actor: Emmanuelle Beart
- Actor: Stéphane Audran
- Actor: Setsuko Hara
- Actor: Isabella Rossellini
- Director: Abbas Kiarostami
- Director: Alfred Hitchcock
- Director: Anthony Mann
- Director: Asghar Farhadi
- Director: Bertrand Tavernier
- Director: Carol Reed
- Director: David Gordon Green
- Director: Don Siegel
- Director: Douglas Sirk
- Director: Eric Rohmer
- Director: Francois Truffaut
- Director: George Sluizer
- Director: Henri-Georges Clouzot
- Director: Hiroshi Teshigahara
- Director: Jacques Audiard
- Director: Jacques Demy
- Director: Jean-Jacques Annaund
- Director: Jean-Luc Godard
- Director: Joe Swanberg
- Director: John Hillcoat
- Director: Joseph Losey
- Director: Jules Dassin
- Director: Kinji Fukasaku
- Director: Kenji Mizoguchi
- Director: Kon Ichikawa
- Director: Leos Carax
- Director: Louis Malle
- Director: Lynn Shelton
- Director: Marcel Carné
- Director: Masaki Kobayashi
- Director: Mathieu Kassovitz
- Director: Max Ophuls
- Director: Michael Winterbottom
- Director: Mike Leigh
- Director: Mikio Naruse
- Director: Paolo Sorrentino
- Director: Ramin Bahrani
- Director: René Clément
- Director: Robert Aldrich
- Director: Robert Bresson
- Director: Roberto Rossellini
- Director: Rouben Mamoulian
- Director: Shane Meadows
- Director: Shion Sono
- Director: Takashi Miike
- Director: Takeshi Kitano
- Director: Terence Davies
- Director: Tobe Hooper
- Director: William A. Wellman
- Director: Agnès Varda
- Director: Jacques Rivette
- Director: Guy Maddin
- Director: Preson Sturges
- Director: Claude Pinoteau
- Watchlist: Random pick from Top 20
- Watchlist: Random pick from Bottom 20
- Watchlist: Random pick from Oldest 20
- Watchlist: Random pick from Newest 20
- Watchlist: Random pick
- Flickchart: 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
- Flickchart: A.V. Club's the New Cult Canon
- Flickchart: Alamo Drafthouse 100
- Flickchart: Artificial Eye
- Flickchart: BBC's 100 Greatest American Films
- Flickchart: Cahiers du cinéma: Top 10 Lists
- Flickchart: Cannes Caméra d'Or Winning
- Flickchart: Cannes Grand Prix
- Flickchart: Cannes Grand Prix du Festival International du Film
- Flickchart: Cannes Jury Prize
- Flickchart: Cannes Palme d'Or Winning
- Flickchart: Cannes Prix du scénario
- Flickchart: Cannes Prix Un Certain Regard
- Flickchart: Cannon Films
- Flickchart: Complex's 100 Best Movies of the Complex Decade
- Flickchart: Complex's 50 Indie Movies You Need to See Before You Die
- Flickchart: Criterion Eclipse
- Flickchart: David di Donatello Award for Best Film Winning
- Flickchart: Elder's Best Film You've Never Seen
- Flickchart: Elder's Film That Changed My Life
- Flickchart: Empire Magazine's 100 Best Films of World Cinema
- Flickchart: European Film Award for Best Film Nominated
- Flickchart: Facets Video
- Flickchart: Film Comment Selects
- Flickchart: French Syndicate of Cinema Critics Prix Léon Moussinac
- Flickchart: French Syndicate of Cinema Critics Prix Méliès Winning
- Flickchart: Gold Hugo Winning
- Flickchart: Golden Bear for Best Film Winning
- Flickchart: Golden Lion Winning
- Flickchart: Hammer Film Productions
- Flickchart: Independent Spirit Award for Best Film Nominated
- Flickchart: Independent Spirit Award for Best Foreign Film Nominated
- Flickchart: Independent Spirit John Cassavetes Award Winning
- Flickchart: Kino International
- Flickchart: Kino Lorber Studio Classics
- Flickchart: L.A. Noire 'Golden Film Reels' Collection
- Flickchart: Leonard Maltin's 151 Best Movies You've Never Seen
- Flickchart: Little White Lies's 100 Great Movies By Female Directors
- Flickchart: London Film Critics' Circle Award for Film of the Year
- Flickchart: London Film Critics' Circle British Film of the Year Winning
- Flickchart: London Film Critics' Circle Foreign Language Film of the Year Winning
- Flickchart: Lux Prize Nominated
- Flickchart: Masters of Cinema
- Flickchart: Moscow International Film Festival Top Prize Winning
- Flickchart: National Board of Review Award for Best Film Winning
- Flickchart: National Film Registry
- Flickchart: National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Film Winning
- Flickchart: New York Film Critics Circle Award for Best Film Winning
- Flickchart: Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Picture Winning
- Flickchart: Paste Magazine's 100 Best "B Movies" of All Time
- Flickchart: Paste Magazine's 100 Best Documentaries of All Time
- Flickchart: Paste Magazine's 100 Best Film Noirs of All Time
- Flickchart: Paste Magazine's 100 Best Martial Arts Movies of All Time
- Flickchart: Paste Magazine's 100 Best Silent Films of All Time
- Flickchart: Paste Magazine's 40 Best Films from the Netherlands
- Flickchart: Quentin Tarantino's Cinematic Influences
- Flickchart: RKO Pictures
- Flickchart: Roger Ebert's Great Movies
- Flickchart: Rolling Thunder Pictures
- Flickchart: Rue Morgue's 200 Alternative Horror Films You Need To See
- Flickchart: Saturn Award for Best Horror or Thriller Film Nominated
- Flickchart: Saturn Award for Best International Film Nominated
- Flickchart: Saturn Award for Best Science Fiction Film Nominated
- Flickchart: Screamfest Best Picture Winning
- Flickchart: Shaw Brothers Studios
- Flickchart: Shôchiku
- Flickchart: Shout! Factory
- Flickchart: Sight & Sound's Greatest Films of All Time Poll
- Flickchart: Silver Bear Jury Grand Prix Winning
- Flickchart: Slant Magazine's 'Best of the Aughts'
- Flickchart: Slant Magzine's 100 Best Films of the 1990s
- Flickchart: Slant Magzine's 100 Essential Films
- Flickchart: Sony Pictures Classics
- Flickchart: Spike Lee's Essential Film List
- Flickchart: Strand Releasing
- Flickchart: Studio Ghibli
- Flickchart: Sundance Selects
- Flickchart: TCM Underground
- Flickchart: the Cinema Guild
TL/DR
-
Movie:The Best of Youth (2003)
-
Rating:3/10
Tags
Related Articles
Latest Articles
-
Silver Screen Streak List #22: 03. Me and Orson Welles (2009)
-
Silver Screen Streak List #22: 02. Red Road (2006)
-
Silver Screen Streak List #22: 01. The Warrior (2001)
-
Popgap Diary: 2022 Movies, in Review
-
Silver Screen Streak List #22: The 28 best films of all time you've probably never seen
-
PopGap Diary: Octoblur 2022 is all Oct-Over now, Baby Blue
-
PopGap Diary: Octoblur 2022
-
Silver Screen Streak List #21: 06. The Pride of the Yankees (1942)
-
Silver Screen Streak List #21: 05. Now, Voyager (1942)
POPGAP Projects
-
Silver Screen Streak List #22: The 28 best films of all time you've probably never seen
-
PopGap Diary: Octoblur 2022 is all Oct-Over now, Baby Blue
-
PopGap Diary: Octoblur 2022
-
Silver Screen Streak List #21: Dramas of the 1940s
-
Popgap Diary: 2021 in Review
-
Silver Screen Streak List #20: 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
-
PopGap Diary: Octoblur 2021 is in the cold, cold ground
-
PopGap Diary: Octoblur 2021
-
Silver Screen Streak List #19: Top Crime Dramas of the 1970s
Popular Articles
-
PopGap Diary: Octoblur 2019
-
Octoblur 2017: Annual Horror-ish Movie Nightmare-a-thon
-
Introducing the Silver Screen Streak movie challenge
-
PopGap #08 Re-cap: Comedies Since 1970
-
Octoblur 2017: R.I.P.!
-
PopGap Diary: Octoblur 2020
-
Octoblur 2015 - It's Over!
-
PopGap #19: Movie Books Special Report
-
Popgap Diary: 2019 in Review